jump to navigation

Up to Spec, but Not What You Want August 18, 2008

Posted by Ian Tang in Uncategorized.
trackback


Have you ever order some food & have a image of what it would be … but you got completely different?   For example: If you order a medium-well burger and imagined a juicy burger with steak like texture; When it arrives, you got a hybrid of sloppy joes & a burger from a big fast-food chain.

You essentially kind of got what you ordered, because it was up to spec, although it was not what you were hoping for. This happens quite a bit in IT; When a user request for an addition part/enhancement to a system.

Here is a common scenario for an enhancement process:
1. use request a change
2. user describe the change
3. Business/system analyst change those description into specifications list
4. Develop get list & figure what the user wants
5. Developer code to spec
6. User gets the change & say that’s not what I was looking for
7. Sent back with a ton of changes to the developer
… everyone is pissed off & think the other people are idiots

What might of went wrong?

  • User could describe what they were looking for in word
  • User described a solution, not the problem
  • Business system analyst didn’t know what the user really wanted
  • Business analyst didn’t emphesize which specs was important/key
  • Developer didn’t know the business need or the reason for the enhancement
  • Developer literally follow the specs word by word
  • With good intentions, the developer added what they think might help the user

Any of this is a very common reason that a IT project often gets delayed & why outsourcing failed for so many. 

As I’m writing this, I ordered a spaghetti bolognese & I got one that smelled & kind of tased like old rags … irk & yet how timely?  =P

Comments»

1. Working with IT: 3 Basics/Essentials « Soft Side of IT - August 22, 2008

[...] IT: 3 Basics/Essentials August 22, 2008 Posted by tangian in Uncategorized. trackback   Last post, I brought up the a basic problem with confusions that come up for anyone that has dealt with [...]